Bud Abbott

Rocky Stonebridge

Lou Costello

Captain 'Puddin' head' Feathergill

Charles Laughton

Capt. William Kidd

Hillary Brooke

Capt. Bonney

Bill Shirley

Bruce Martingale

Leif Erickson

Morgan

Fran Warren

Lady Jane

Chuck Roberson

Pirate (uncredited)

Paul Newlan

Pub Owner (uncredited)

Harry Wilson

Ugly Pirate (uncredited)

Joe Kirk

Flirtatious Pirate (uncredited)

Suzanne Ridgway

Pretty Maiden in Pub (uncredited)