Rachel Alig

Billie

Amber Herfurth

Harley

Sean Walsh

Sam

Nick Chandler

Carl

Pat Garrigan

Diglett

Alex Dittmer

Steve 'The Watchman'

Heather Call

Brenda 'The Dreadful Ghoul'

Grace Reinhardt

Grace

Tyler Amm

Richard

Chris Aubry

The Assassin

Andrew Baker

Baby Brute

Chris Baker

Papa Brute

Emily Baker

Cult

Katie Baker

Cult Stand In

Alex Bergman

The Monitor

Matthew Birtell

Cult Stand In

Ethan Boin

Cult

Caylee Bourdoin

Christmas Girl

Avery Buckingham

Avery

Joe Buckley

Cult Sacrifice, Cult Stand In

Jennie Carpenter

Cult

Amber Cassell

Cult

Dan Churney

Cult Preacher

Zander Dziedzic

Cult

Hunter Faux

Cult

Allie Fishman

Game Booth Carny

Micheal Flaherty

Cult

Sloan Gretencord

Bar Patron

Daniel James Halm

Doug's Bloody Friend

Bryan Michael Hartnett

Cult

Natalia Ann Hrovat

The Hag

Dakota Hungerford

Cult

Sylvia Hyatt

Cult

Joe Jakupcak

Cult Stand In

Pawel Kaniewski

Lanky Brute, Demon

Ashley Keegan

Kennedy

Mackenzie Killelea

Waitress

Quinn Kistenferger

Waitress

Andrea Lippert

Bar Patron

Matthew Maggio

Cult

Mario Manrriquez

Bar Patron

Trevor McCandless

Doug

Sam Michaels

Cult Stand In

Jacob Montgomery

Cult

Kelly Montgomery

Cult

Evan Morency

Cult

Paul D. Morgan

Officer Henderson

Randy Noy

Bar Patron

Edgar Patino

Pee Pants 'The Spared'

Craig Peck

Craig

Patricia Pruitt

Waitress

Marcos Rabadan

Marcos

Miranda Reinhardt

Grace's Mother

Ryan Satterfeal

Cult (as Nicholas Scott)

Kristopher Smith

Cult Tech Guy

Emily Swain

Cult Stand In

Nick Swartz

Undead 'Puppet' Half-Goat

Karly Swords

Christmas Girl

Blake Tyson

Cult

Jim Uremovic

Cotton Candy Man

Giuseppe Urso

Marc

Benjamin Van Vactor

Bartender

Sara Bonnie Walsh

The Bra Carney

Emily Weber

Game Booth Carny

Kyle Wilkinson

Kyle

Marc Wilkinson

Phil Gunderson

Rebecca Wilkinson

Cult Stand In

Ryan Matthew Ziegler

Game Booth Carny