Klinton Spilsbury

The Lone Ranger / John Reid

Christopher Lloyd

Maj. Bartholomew 'Butch' Cavendish

Matt Clark

Sheriff Wiatt

Juanin Clay

Amy Striker

Jason Robards

President Ulysses S. Grant

John Bennett Perry

Ranger Captain Dan Reid

David Hayward

Ranger Collins

Richard Farnsworth

Wild Bill Hickok

Michael Horse

Tonto

Marc Gilpin

Young John Reid

John Hart

Lucas Striker

Lincoln Tate

Gen. George A. Custer

Ted Flicker

Buffalo Bill Cody

Bonita Granville

Woman (uncredited)

Patrick Montoya

Young Tonto

David Bennett

General Aurelio Rodriguez

Ted White

Jonathan Reid

Chere Rae

Mrs. Reid

Robert F. Hoy

Lieutenant Perlmutter

Ted Gehring

Dale Wesley Stillwell

Buck Taylor

Robert Edward Gattlin

Chuck Hayward

Wald (Cavendish gang)