Tom Lipinski

Dom McGuire

Adelaide Clemens

Deb Catalano

Tammy Blanchard

Melissa

Giancarlo Esposito

Father Heery

Kristen Connolly

Betsy

Will Rogers

Kevin

Valerie Harper

Kathryn

Bobby Moynihan

Roddy

Robert Arensen

Physical therapist patient

Jo Armeniox

Christine

John Auer

Acting Student

Jackie Brown

Parishioner

Thomas Brucia

Barbershopper #2

John Cariani

Odd Interviewer

JR Carter

Parishioner

Rob Yang

Fred

Paloma Guzmán

Jennifer

Larry Clarke

Mike

Maria Dizzia

Serious Lady

Loudon Wainwright III

Tom

Stephanie Sherry

Acting Student

Kate Reinders

Mary

Kerry O'Malley

Theresa

Kianné Muschett

Eager Lady

Thomas Middleditch

Game Guy

Brendan O'Malley

Chad

Frank Harts

Khakis

David Dantowitz

Barbershopper #1

Hal Cohen

Barbershopper #3

Dominic Colón

Hefty Dude

Steve DiNardo

Bar Patron

Mike Finazzo

Acting Student

Tara Layne

Party Guest

Johnny M. Wu

Rick

Frank Baba

Extra (uncredited)

Marmee Regine Cosico

Parishioner (uncredited)

Traci Redmond

Party Guest (uncredited)