Jackie Kelly

Carrie/Mermaid/Charlotte

Bill Oberst Jr.

William

Debbie Rochon

Elizabeth

David Wassilak

Dr. Tom

Blaire Winter

Elizabeth (1980s)

Peter Joseph Lewis

Mortician (Voice)

Jim Allen

Mortician (Body)

Shawn I. Chevalier

Grace

Steve Montana

Chuck

Dalton Littrell

Avery

Shelby Bouren

Madison

Victoria Mullen

Sylvia

Carla TenBroek

Doris

Don McClendon

Percy

Jason Christ

Orderly

Eric Stanze

Stan

Stephen Potter

Dr. Eggers

Vickie Doerr

Head Nurse

Gus Stevenson

Concerned Nurse

Karen Druley

Sympathetic Nurse

James Ross

Pill Doctor

Charlie Butler

Young Carrie

Luci Manno

Christine

Stephanie Zhong

Train Attendant

Mike Ketcher

Husband

Sabrina Alstat

Wife