Tommy Flanagan

Michael

Gary Stretch

Duck

Sarah Graham Hayes

Amity

Dean Sansone

Larry Gold

Keith Randolph Smith

Lenny

David Fonteno

Benny

Peter Greene

Marcus Devlin

Torri Singer

8-Year-Old Amity

Eric Tonken

16-Year-Old Michael

Del Pentecost

Southern Cop

Stephanie Silk

Denise the Waitress

Michael McCormick

Walter

Victor Mastroianni

Jeff the Clerk

Jeff Shore

Moe

Tania Deighton

Jamie

Peter James

Justin

Dennis Yeandle

Marty Greenburg

Alice Saltzman

Brenda Greenburg

Louie Leonardo

Groom

Christy Payette

Bride

Greg Cilmi Jr.

Amity's Father