Ryan Krawczyk

Self

Janet Krawczyk

Self

Jeremy Rettig

Paranormal Team Leader

Jill Witecki

Theatre Caretaker

Karen Santiago

Psychic

Michelle Orwick

Psychic

Andrew Mullen

Historian

Joyce Duncan

Lighthouse Caretaker

Thomas Kontos Craddock

Fink Finley

Denise Altman

Antique Shop Caretaker

Larry Altman

Antique Shop Caretaker

Harry Anderson

Self (archive footage)

Neil Gaiman

Self

Amanda Palmer

Self

Sara Smith

Paranormal Investigator

Mike Waldman

Paranormal Investigator

Pam Waldman

Paranormal Investigator

Kelcie Lloyd

Lighthouse Keeper