Cosmo DiNardo

Self - Murderer

Bonnie Finocchiaro

Self - Dean's Mother

Anthony Finocchiaro

Self - Dean's Father

Dean Finocchiaro

Self - Murder Victim

Gary Forrester

Self - (Former) Solebury Township Police Department

Megan Freer

Self - Middletown Township Police Department

Corey Johnson

Narrator (voice)

Tom Kline

Self - Finocchiaro's Attorney

Jonathan Koretzky

Self - Solebury Township Police Department

Sean Kratz

Self - Murderer

Tom Meo

Self - Murder Victim

Jimi Patrick

Self - Murder Victim

Sharon Patrick

Self - Jimi's Grandmother

Tom Sofield

Self - Reporter

Phillip Steinberg

Police Officer