Kathy Baker

Nora

Ron Eldard

Tom

Gale Harold

Elliott

John Mahoney

Gene

Samantha Mathis

Jenny

Vinessa Shaw

Nell

Bradley Whitford

Anthony

Joanna Gleason

Silvia

Lisa Edelstein

Irene

Jessalyn Gilsig

Dianne

Abigail Spencer

Clarissa

Meredith Monroe

Young Nora

Shad Hart

Nick

Tyler Patrick Jones

Nick 10-12 years old

Reiko Aylesworth

Business Woman

Aidan Forte

Infant Nick

Aaron Marchbank

Toddler Nick

Max Burkholder

Nick at 5

Austen Nunn

Michael

Nicholas Spera

Boy with Dog

Paul Gutrecht

Simon

Emmanuel Xuereb

Phil

Steven Petrarca

Carl

Phillip Rhys

Ron

Rose Portillo

Nurse

Joseph Bologna

Noah

Barbara Barrie

Ruth

Vinessa Shaw

Neil

Rabbi Mordecai Finley

Rabbi

Clea DuVall

Laura (uncredited)

Tom Bower

Vito (uncredited)

Jessalyn Gilsig

Dianne (uncredited)

Kathryn Joosten

Gene's Mom (uncredited)

Dominic Scott Kay

Elliott (age 4) (uncredited)

Silas Weir Mitchell

Max (uncredited)

Adam Pinkstaff

Man in Truck (uncredited)

Lawrence Pressman

Max's Father (uncredited)

Aram Rappaport

Theatre Audience Member (uncredited)

Erik Rusnak

Theatre Camp (uncredited)