Anastasia Elfman

Babysitter (segment "Overkill")

Jennifer Nangle

Malvolia (segment "Malvolias Halloween Monster Marathon")

Phyllis Spielman

Mrs McClaron ("A Samhain Liturgy") / Sister Mary ("Sister Mary")

Bianca Allaine

The Woman (segment "Treaters")

Matt Block

The Man / Devil (segment "Sister Mary")

Lauren Fogle

Hot Chick (segment "Overkill")

Jordan Beltz

Allison (segment "Treaters")

Sable Griedel

Kira (segment "Treaters")

Marissa Sabatucci

Rachel (segment "Treaters")

Adam Hershberger

Narrator (segment "Treaters") (voice

Mark Combs

Christine (segment "Trucksquatch")

William Davis

The Husband (segment "The Candy Taker")

Greg Palinkas

The Friend (segment "The Candy Taker")

Angelina Prendergast

The Screamer (segment "The Candy Taker")

Christopher Hoban

Luis (segment "The October Kids")

Lexi Breuer

Tara (segment "The October Kids")

Emily Swenson

Jenna (segment "The October Kids")

R.J. Wagner

Stan (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")

Chad Bruns

Tim (segment "Treaters")

Gabriel Bulthaup

Baby (segment "Sister Mary")

Tim Novotny

Creature / Cocaine Guy #2 (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")

Tania Henderson

Holly's Mom (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")

Ty Sells

Cameron (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")

Rhema Srihartiti

Holly (segment "A Samhain Liturgy")

Zeke Hanson

Police Officer (segment "The October Kids")

Jessica Breuer

Kevin's Mom (segment "The October Kids")

Maddox Breuer

Kevin (segment "The October Kids")