Liev Schreiber

Drew Hagel

Marisa Tomei

Carrie Manning

Peter Sarsgaard

Quint Manning

Maya Hawke

Shannon Hagel

Alex Wolff

Ian Warfield

Betty Gabriel

Ronnie Hagel

Aasif Mandvi

Godeep

Paul Sparks

Jon

Fred Hechinger

Jamie Manning

John Ventimiglia

David

Dominic Colón

Roberto Jarvis

James Waterston

Andy

Fredric Lehne

Detective Flowers

Daryl Edwards

Detective Gore

Greta Quispe

Nanny

Alex Yiakoumatos

Manning Twin #1

Nick Yiakoumatos

Manning Twin #2

Carson McCalley

Tim

Julia Greer

WMV Associate

Mark Blum

Rex

Eva Kaminsky

Diane

David Gibson

Headmaster

Marisa Ryan

Ella

Maxwell Whittington-Cooper

Brendon

Loni Ackerman

Carrie's Mother

Aaron Roman Weiner

Trainer

Christiane Seidel

Godeep's Wife

Madeline Scanlon

Emily

Rachelle Carson-Begley

News Reporter

Greta Watson

Reporter #1

Lawrence Smith

Relentless Reporter

Amanda Barron

Journalist

Michael Wren Gucciardo

Toby (Banker at Quints House) (uncredited)

Blair Lewin

Young Carrie (uncredited)

Ron Maestri

Parent (uncredited)

Christine McCann

Board Member (uncredited)