Mary Martin

Annie Oakley

John Raitt

Frank Butler

William O'Neal

Colonel 'Buffalo' Bill Cody

Reta Shaw

Dolly Tate

Donald Burr

Charlie Davenport

Norman Edwards

Tommy Keller

Susan Luckey

Winnie Tate

Zachary Charles

Chief Sitting Bull

Robert Nash

Gordon William 'Pawnee Bill' Lillie

Stuart Hodes

Wild Horse

Jan Skidmore

Nellie Oakley

Patricia Morrow

Jessie Oakley

Luke Halpin

Little Jake Oakley

Shelley Windsor

Little Girl

John Eldredge

Foster Wilson

Robert Banas

Indian Dancer (uncredited)

Dennis Bonilla

Indian Twin (uncredited)

Thomas Bonilla

Indian Twin (uncredited)