Peter Gallagher

Himself / Sky Masterson

Nathan Lane

Himself / Nathan Detroit

Jossie DeGuzman

Herself / Sarah Brown

Faith Prince

Herself / Miss Adelaide

Walter Bobbie

Himself / Nicely-Nicely Johnson

John Carpenter

Himself / Arvide Abernathy

Steve Ryan

Himself / Lt. Brannigan

Ernie Sabella

Himself / Harry the Horse

J.K. Simmons

Himself / Benny Southstreet

Herschel Sparber

Himself / Big Jule

Ruth Williamson

Herself / General Matilda B. Cartwright

Jerry Zaks

Himself