Michael Ian Black

Michael

Michael Showalter

Michael

David Wain

David

Nina Hellman

David's Cousin's Wife / Poker Wife / Brooklyn Girl

Josh Hamilton

David's Cousin Greg

Rosadel Varela

Taco Woman

Zach Galifianakis

Santa

Francie Swift

Santa's Wife

Peter Salett

Sherpa / Indian / Terrorist / Policeman / Park Dancer

Bradley Cooper

Yoga Student / Satan

Paul Rudd

John

Zak Orth

Turkey Hunter / Christmas Caroler / Inspector / Enos / Friend

A.D. Miles

Christmas Caroler / Pilgrim / Wiffleball Player / Fishing Husband

Martha Black

Christmas Caroler

Heidi Neurauter

Christmas Caroler / College Buddy / Angel / Brooklyn Girl

Scott Sowers

Dad / Poker Player

Joe Lo Truglio

Johnson / Indian / Wiffleball Player / Mugger

Angela Galyean

Pilgrim

Ian Helfer

College Buddy / Office Person / General Thornbush

Marisa Ryan

College Buddy

Christina Kirk

College Buddy / Terrorist / Fishing Wife

Leo Allen

College Buddy

Jenny Maguire

Office Person / Lady Richington

Todd Holoubek

Office Person

Joanne Solomon

Office Person

Ben Shenkman

Hans

Sam Rockwell

Pizza Guy

Glenn Kessler

Jarvis the Butler

Stuart Blumberg

Major Gentry

Ali Marsh

Maid

Callie Thorne

Yoga Teacher

Elizabeth Banks

Yoga Student

Amy Miles

Yoga Student

Matt Ballard

Poker Player / Park Dancer

Julie Bowen

Mother Nature

Amy Carlson

Park Dancer

John Roberts

Park Dancer

Julie Dingman

Park Dancer

Seth Herzog

Park Dancer

Amy Rice

Cat Girl