Donald Trump

Self (archive footage)

Mindy Robinson

Grace The Reporter

Dywayne Thomas

John Murphy

Lia Marie Johnson

(archive footage)

Shane Ryan-Reid

Brandon

Sabrina Culver

Stacy Miller

Ice Cool

Chad

Ken Holmes

Miguel 'Snakeskin' Perez

Cris Cochrane

Samael 'Sam' Dubhan

Leah Coonce

Karen

Barack Obama

Self (archive footage)

Josh Outzen

Ted Bundy Admirer

Gary Lee Vincent

Agent Walker

Mark Valeriano

Michael Lake

Jared Oakley

Marc Hockl

Sophia Cacciola

Kelly Thompson (segment: Cable 54 News - Why Do Killers Kill?)

Brandi Aguilar

Piper Lopez

Kelley Wilson Robinson

Roxie

Glenn Berggoetz

Bill Carl

Emily McKinley Hill

Jason Impey

Officer Joe Newton

Acadia Colan

Serena

Richard Chandler

Biker

Tony Newton

Navah Raphael

Parker Rhodes

Delaney Vallese

Victim's Sister

Steven Perillo

Interviewee

Rosann Ferrier

Jan Parsons - Criminal Psychology

Hunter Otto

Hunter Schmidt

Bryden Elliott DiGennaro

Victim's Friend

Derrick Gilbert

Young kid

Gant Montgomery

Officer Thompson

Urszula Makowska

Interviewee

Chuck Chapman

Johnny Starr

Thomas Gangstad

Crazy fan

Roberto Ragone

Detective Mark Agnello / President of Necrophiliacs Anonymous

Axle Gunn

Detective

Travis Lance Sosa

Robert

Josh Hayes

Dr. Ian Gensuse (segment "Sue")

Klaudia Lucia Wyzykiewicz

Actress

Val Tannuzzi

Alejandra Gomez

Nick Charles

Serial Killer Fan

Maude Michaud

Sara (segment "Made For You")

Dean Houlihan

Simon / Killer

Steve Mack

Brandons Nephew

O'Neil Thomas

Interviewee

Kevin Lapham

Det. Wilson Brown

Luc Bernier

Martin (segment "Made For You")

Chris Miller

Deranged Interviewer

Spencer Mathis

Roman Brion

V (Segment "Fear the Ghetto Killer")

Iris Crenshaw

Criminal Psychologist

Justine Colan

Cousin #2

Dena Navarroli

Michaela Lillestol

Lilith Singson

Suzana Trifkovic

Victim's Friend

Carly Richardson

Sam

Scott Geiter

Family Friend

Chris Pinto

Miles Thornbush

Rose Pendleton

Scott Bray

Tom Smith

Gino DiNardo

Connor Komoroski

Ted Bundy Fan

Petey Hixson

Killer in Van #2

Teresa Tuttle

Reid's mom

Robert Alesandro

Max Caulfield

Gregor Collins

Jeronomo Rozebush

Jeynelle Dean-Hayes

Sue Tralfero (segment "Sue")

Bradley Louis Kramer

Louie

Vincent Maeder

Ralph Witkins

Tom Culo

Doctor

Lluvia Almanza

Amanda Marie

Nancy Pinto

Annabelle Thornbush

Krister Twizz Forsberg

Victim

Judith Etzelstorfer

Witness

Vex X. Starskream

Perpetrator

Timothy Patrick O'Neill

Jimmy Champane

Mike (segment "Poetry in That")

Luke Y. Thompson

Jagger Trouant

Drew Holland

Jerry O' Nofre

Conspiracy Guy

Stefanie Slack

Girl in Van #2

Devin Williams

Jimmy

Eddie Forsberg

Young Brandon

Rhys Griffin

Adrian

Brenda Carey

Harper Bennet

Shelley Fairbanks

Zoey 'FreaqShow' Peterson

Holly Ruth Bailey

Karen

Pierce Bunch

James Hartley

Alan McLoughlin

Alan

Doug Christman

Branden Vives

Interviewee

Ralitsa Chobanova

Dean Michael Smith

J.R. Wilson

Dwight Cooke

Junior (segment "Cruel Yule")

Amish

Bella Farris

Victim's Sister

Larry McKenzie

Cheyanne Allison

Eric Cire

Dave (segment "Poetry in That")

Kirse Cosey

young Reid

Anthony Caligiuri

Enya d'Entremont

Cousin #1

Beatrix Victoria

Victim (segment "Cruel Yule")

Rachael Kim-Ainsworth

Reporter (voice)

Ashley Smith

Ashley

Carla Dawn d'Entremont

Cameron Patrick

Brandon Marc Powers

Owen Walsh

Abbie Williams

Ruby Collingwood

Tessa Hold

Saveaya Oz

Pearl

Eveline Dunlap

Jenna Renee

Victim

Samari Clark

Roe

Jean Joseph

Jean

Carl d'Entremont

Firsherman

Paolo Vanoli

Brandon Fan (segment "Brandon Lives")

Greg Boyea

Ron Stone

Jeremy Maury

Jeremy

Jennifer White

Aleksandra Brown

Girl in Van #1

Tina Matasari

Raped Girl (segment "Brandon Lives")

Michael Andrick

Amanda DaSilva

Garrett D. West

Danny Stevens

Corey Seaver

Peyton Prescott

Hunter Smith

Hunter