Bill Elliott

Red Ryder

Robert Blake

Little Beaver

Alice Fleming

Duchess Wentworth, Red's Aunt

Peggy Stewart

Hazel Parker

Russell Simpson

Colonel Parker

Dick Curtis

Chopin - the Harmonica Killer

Joel Friedkin

Murphy

Kenne Duncan

Henchman Felton

Tom London

Sheriff Peabody

Monte Hale

Pete - Driver That Quits

Wen Wright

The Idaho Kid

Dickie Dillon

Broken Arrow

Mary Arden

Stage Passenger

Jack Kirk

Stage passenger

James Mitchell

Townsman (uncredited)