Alison Brie

Sister Alessandra

Dave Franco

Masseto

Kate Micucci

Sister Ginevra

Aubrey Plaza

Sister Fernanda

John C. Reilly

Father Tommasso

Molly Shannon

Sister Marea

Fred Armisen

Bishop Bartolomeo

Jemima Kirke

Marta

Lauren Weedman

Francesca

Nick Offerman

Bruno

Paul Reiser

Ilario

Adam Pally

Guard Paolo

Paul Weitz

Lurco

Jon Gabrus

Guard Gregorio

Rolando Abbarchi

Old Man Priest

Teresa Marini

Viola

Dina Lenzi

Elderly Nun

Maria Irene Vetrano

Nun

Letizia Giuntini

Nun

Samanta Gualtieri

Nun

Sena Lippi

Nun

Sonia Luscia

Nun

Margherita Ferri

Nun

Anna Maria Baldocchi

Witch

Benedetta Guintini

Witch

Benedetta Spinetti

Witch

Carla Buscemi

Witch

Elisa Pierini

Witch

Laura Salvini

Witch

Marta Petracchi

Witch

Rossana Bena

Witch

Rossella Ambrosini

Witch

Sara Venut

Witch

Teresa Recchia

Witch

Vanessa Villa

Witch

Colin DeMartini

Servant

Fabio Magnani

Servant

Luca Rondinini

Servant

Luigi Biava

Servant

Pierfrancesco Melley

Servant

Paolo Preziuso

Servant