Jay Baruchel

Reed Fish

Alexis Bledel

Kate

Victor Rasuk

Frank Cortez

Schuyler Fisk

Jill

A. J. Cook

Theresa

Katey Sagal

Maureen

Shiri Appleby

Jill Cavanaugh

Chris Parnell

Ralph

Valerie Azlynn

Kate Peterson

DJ Qualls

Andrew

Blake Clark

Irv

Tommy Dewey

Rex

Jim Cody Williams

Cowboy

Boti Bliss

Waitress

Rossif Sutherland

Gabe

David Beggs

Farmer

Jackie Benoit

Imogene Sandstrom

Eugene Smith

Preacher

Reed Fish

John Penner

Peter Alwazzan

Radio Show Caller (voice)

Scott Laster

Floyd Fish (voice)

Todd Fjelsted

Bartender (uncredited)