Kelli O'Hara

Julie Jordan

Nathan Gunn

Billy Bigelow

John Cullum

The Starkeeper

Jessie Mueller

Carrie Pipperidge

Jason Danieley

Enoch Snow

Shuler Hensley

Jigger

Kate Burton

Mrs. Mullin

Robert Fairchild

Carnival Boy

Tiler Peck

Louise

Ben Rosenfield

Enoch Snow, Jr.

Audra McDonald

Host