Tom Everett Scott

Dave Holden

David Moscow

Tom Holden

Cara Buono

Rachel

David Lowery

Billy

Denis O'Hare

Father

Michael Kelly

Frankie

Leo Burmester

Judge Perkins

Tibor Feldman

Dr. Harry Fields

James Murtaugh

Chief Bascomb

Michael Angarano

Young Tom

Peter Anthony Tambakis

Young Dave

Ted Travelstead

Gas Attendant

Marcia DeBonis

Sara

Chris Cantwell

Mr. Taylor

Andrew Van Dusen

Convenience Store Clerk

Jefferson Taffet

Young Store Clerk

Mella Fazzoli

Timmy the Mechanic

Charle Landry

Mike Sanel

Christopher Petrosino

Store Clerk's Son

Jenni Gallagher

Denise

Chris McGinn

Woman in Store

Andrew Sikking

Liquor Store Clerk

Louis Ludwig

Elderly Clerk

John Lally

Mr. Orton

Trudy Lally

Mrs. Orton

Gary Kauffman

Prosecutor

Pete 'Conan' Winebrake

Defense Attorney

Daniel Prucell

Boy at Sara's