James Stewart

Tom Jeffords

Jeff Chandler

Cochise

Debra Paget

Sonseeahray 'Morningstar'

Basil Ruysdael

General Oliver

Will Geer

Rancher

Joyce Mackenzie

Terry

Arthur Hunnicutt

Milt Duffield

Robert Adler

Lonergan - Stage Driver

Trevor Bardette

Stage Passenger

Chris Willow Bird

Nochalo

Raymond Bramley

Col. Bernall

Chet Brandenburg

Miner

Argentina Brunetti

Nalikadeya - Cochise's Wife

Harry Carter

Miner

Iron Eyes Cody

Teese, Court Jester

J.W. Cody

Pionsenay - Chosen Warrior

Heinie Conklin

Townsman

John Doucette

Mule Driver

Nacho Galindo

Barber

Robert Griffin

John Lowrie

Jack Kenny

Townsman

Bob Kortman

Minor Role

Mickey Kuhn

Bob Slade

Al Kunde

Townsman

Ted Mapes

Mail Rider

Frank McGrath

Barfly

Charles Morton

Townsman

Jay Silverheels

Geronimo

Charles Soldani

Skinyea - Chosen Warrior

John War Eagle

Nahilzay

Billy Wilkerson

Juan

Bud Wolfe

Man

Richard Van Opel

Bernall's Adjutant (uncredited)

Dorothy Teters

Indian (uncredited)

Allen D. Sewall

Barfly (uncredited)

John Rice

Townsman (uncredited)

Edwin Rand

Sergeant (uncredited)

John Marston

Maury (uncredited)

Jack Lee

Boucher (uncredited)