Louisa Krause

Jane

Gabriel Ebert

Jack

Eliza Dushku

Bianca

Polly Draper

Mom

Amir Arison

Rob

Jon Bass

Steve

Lindsay Arber

Peaseblossom

Franco Gonzalez

Jose

Gregg Edelman

Father

Sal Ardisi

Audience Member (as Salvatore Ardisi)

Margaret Donlin

Laughing Woman

Gary Hilborn

Gyp

Greg Keller

Paul

Benj Mirman

Friend 1

Kristina Mueller

Mustardseed

Anisha Nagarajan

Cynthia

Nathaniel Peart

Lysander

Nicole Pursell

Bookstore Worker

Lance Roberts

Waiter

Bianca Rutigliano

Friend 2

Paulina Simkin

Shakespeare Lover

Nick Stevenson

Director

Margaux Susi

Friend 3

Sarah Wharton

Kim

Stephen Dexter

Demetrius/Holyman/Various(voice) (uncredited)

Jesse Luciani

Theater patron(uncredited)

Yamileth Palacios

Restaurant Patron(uncredited)