Miranda Rhyne

Angela

Charlotte Eve Blythe

Ellie

Anna Thomson

Mae

John Ventimiglia

Andrew

iO Tillett Wright

Sam

Vincent Gallo

Preacher

Ruth Maleczech

Sleepwalker

Garrett Bemer

Tom

Peter Facinelli

Lucifer

Hynden Walch

Darlene

Henry Stram

Man at Fair

Caitlin Hall

Anne

Francis Conroy

Anne's Mother

Gerard Lyons III

Anne's Father

Rodger L. Phillips

Frank

William McKnight

Greg

Jack O'Connell

Man at Bar

Nurith Cohn

Makeover Woman

Constance McCord

The Virgin Mary

Roxana Stuart

Saleslady