Adam Brody

Rocks

Wyatt Cenac

Gunderson

Danny Jacobs

Billy

Josh Lawson

Jake

Amber Tamblyn

Tabatha

Lauren Miller Rogen

Emma

Scott Adsit

Priest

Jon Glaser

Donkey

Zuzanna Szadkowski

CeCe

Matthew Daddario

Peter

Sondra James

Barb

Josh Mostel

Chuck MacArthur

David Lipman

Rabbi

Will Beinbrink

Joe

Allyce Beasley

Jeanne

Andrea Leigh

Alexis Ostrander

Ted Oyama

Larry Kim

Melissa Navia

Raja

Suni Reyes

Rita

Lucy Walters

Melanie

Connor Fox

Alex

Darren Grodsky

Zeke (Captain Hook)

Anthony Lumia

Ricky

Bruce Wexler

Massimo

Michael Armstrong Barr

Doctor

Athena Alexis

Nurse (as Athenas Duché)

Alison Mitzner

Nurse (as Ali Mitzner)

Danielle Lee Greaves

Nurse

Haleigh Ciel

Hot Stoner Chick

Annabelle Attanasio

Curious Student

Adam Celentano

SAT Student

Ari Hader

SAT Student (as Arielle Hader)

Princy Thomas

SAT Student

Mikaela Brandon

Inquisitive Student

Fenton Li

Neighbor

Jaden Michael

Street Kid

Aleksandra Myrna

Cafe Patron

Merritt Chase

Shop Owner (as Merritt Matthew Chase)

Kitty Crystal

DJ (as Crystal Lonneberg)

Dan Sheynin

Church Tour Guide

Vin Scialla

Church Visitor

Alanna Dachille

Tourist

Amanda Riley

Bartender

Daniela Dakich

Liquor Store Patron

Darryle Jermaine

Coffee Shop Guest

And Palladino

Pizza Customer

Gus Renaud

Pizza Customer

Kenneth Kopolovicz

Guy Walking out of Pizzaria

Helene Macaulay

Woman in the Park

Bennie Road

Police Officer

Bianca Nejat

Bridesmaid

Demetrius Constant

Boy 1

Christian Dell'Edera

Hispanic Boy

Gabriela Duarte

Girl in Bodega

Janelle Forgette

Party Guest

Joseph Cornacchia

Party Guest

Joseph Gillen

Party Guest