Ben Gazzara

Frank Cavallo

Rita Moreno

Maggie Cavallo

Alanna Ubach

Peggy

Burt Young

Bobby

Vincent Pastore

Joey

Heather Matarazzo

Donna

Lillo Brancato

Pete

Shawn Elliott

The Ambassador

Zach Braff

Young Fred

Victor Argo

Tony

David Thornton

Frank's Father

Chris Orbach

Frank Junior

Brian Vincent

Mac

Mario Macaluso

Young Jimmy

Lisa Altomare

Italian Aunt

Celia Austin

Zoe

Claudia Besso

Joan

Kelly Bishop

Peggy's Mother

Eric Blitz

Young Frank

Sam Coppola

Bill

Mario D'Elia

Italian Uncle

Joseph D'Onofrio

Cousin Vinny

Anthony Damica

Johnny

Marie DeCicco

Frank's mother

Gina Gallagher

Dolores

Susan Jon-Koski-Reino

Italian Aunt

Greg Kachejian

Vincent

Anna Mastroianni

Anna

Sara Moon

Karen

Anne Morea

Michelle

Chris Orbach

Frank Jr

Dave Salerno

Italian Uncle

Rocco Sisto

Fred

Russ Vigilante

Young Bobby

Maggie Wagner

Angela

Jerry Della Salla

Michelle's Date (uncredited)

Lee Gallagher

Toasting Couple (uncredited)

Vincent Gallagher

Toasting Couple (uncredited)