Richard Egan

Father Eusibio Francisco Kino

Ricardo Montalban

Gen. Lafuente

John Ireland

Father Mora

Joseph Campanella

Father at San Bruno Mission

Cesar Romero

Adm. Juan Atondo

Michael Ansara

Chief Coxi

Keenan Wynn

Father at Trading Mission

John Russell

Capt. Solis

Rory Calhoun

Capt. Juan Monje

Anthony Caruso

Father Rodriguez

Aldo Ray

Mine Boss

Victor Jory

Father Zaya

William Dozier

Father Argula

Tris Coffin

Father Francesco Saeta (as Tris Coffin)

Stephen McNally

Father Juan Salvatierra (uncredited)