Cam Gigandet

Rich Johnson

Nick Thune

Rich's Penis

Katherine Cunningham

Lindsay Young

Kevin Miller

Josh Nelson

Jessica Joy

Emily

Katie Rich

Samantha

Holly Houk

Kimi

Jamie Chung

Jamie

Bradley Grant Smith

Former Best Friend

George Lako

Strip Club Patron

Meg Thalken

Doctor

Karen Woditsch

Mother

Casey Tutton

Teenage Girl

Danny Rhodes

Waiter

James E. Foley

Bob (voice)

James R. Doherty

Blond Guy

Rammel Chan

Chinese Delivery Guy

Megan Kohl

Mature Woman

Emily Tumen

Catholic Teen Girl

Justin Kline

Pharmacy Tech

Al Marchesi

Strip Club Patron

Gena Ellis

Aunt Judy

Christin Marie Nichols

Yoga Girl

Catherine Perzee

Lindsay's Sister

J. Anthony Kopec

Businessman Club Patron

Vince Tolentino

The Video Game Nerd

Ben Kirberger

Offensive Gay Stereotype Waiter

Cory Kahane

Teenage Boy

Jodie Glass

Shopper

Katie Hamilton

Catholic Teen Girl

Laura Kallmeyer

Club Girl

Monte LaMonte

Cop

Rita Younan

Club Girl

Brooke Berg

Chicago Police Officer

Anthony E. Cabral

Man in Front of Hardware Store