Phil Silvers

Fletcher Bissell III, The Silver Dollar Kid

Jack Benny

Chicken Finsterwald

Ted de Corsia

Black Bart

Jack Elam

Ike Dalton

Karl Lukas

Jake Dalton

Robert J. Wilke

Billy the Kid Blake

Lee Van Cleef

Sam Bass

George Keymas

Jud McCory

John Dierkes

'Wild Bill' Monks

Mauritz Hugo

'Doc' Henley

Edward Brophy

The Bartender

William Fawcett

'Skunk' Sloan

Jean Willes

Kathy McQueen

Parley Baer

Collingswood

Jack Albertson

Col. Carl Dexter

Tom Fadden

Jedd Slocum

Marion Ross

Elsie May Slocum

Kathie Browne

Lulu Belle Slocum

Bella Bruck

Indian Woman

Byron Foulger

The Clerk

Hallene Hill

Mrs. Hotchkiss

Bill Catching

A Horseman

Don C. Harvey

A Sheriff

Dennis Moore

A Man

George Chandler

Simpson

Alan Dexter

The Husband

Jeanne Bates

The Wife

Billy Booth

The Son

Gina Gillespie

The Daughter

Bruce Cabot

Nick Nolan

Pierce Lyden

Car Mechanic (uncredited)

Art Felix

Townsman (uncredited)

Sid Troy

Townsman (uncredited)

Tex Holden

Townsman (uncredited)

Fox O'Callahan

Townsman (uncredited)