Josie Davis

Carol Cavanaugh

Mayim Bialik

Maggie Goldman

Joanna Clare Scott

Joan Branson

Claire Bloom

Eleanor

Chita Rivera

Giannina

Renée Taylor

Golda

Michael Boatman

Special Angel Albert

Steven Roy

Paul

Nathan Anderson

Stephen

Larry Sullivan

Nate

Dee Wallace

Susan

Jennifer Kindhouse

Sheryl

Bryce Lenon

Jonathan Branson

Joanne Baron

Mrs. Goldman

Anne DeSalvo

Mia Cacciani

Gabriel Bologna

Alan

Christopher Cheaney

Caterer #2

Erick Esteban

Coffee Store Clerk

Dana E. Kowalski

Aloof Server

Mary-Margaret Lewis

Melanie Rosen

Bryan Lukasik

Party Guy

Alice Manning

Mrs. Minslavski

Michael McClendon

Darren

Mike McKelly

Brad

Anna K. McKown

Beth

David Monahan

Jim Sanderson

Jill Moton

Darren's Mother

Nicolas Pangborn

Doug

Suzanne Parish

Minnie Rosen

Jeff Patterson

Toby

John Pecora

Michael Cacciani

Ted Raimi

Angel

Michael Ryan Way

Bouncer