Tony Goldwyn

Joshua

F. Murray Abraham

Father Tardone

Kurt Fuller

Father Pat Hayes

Stacy Edwards

Maggie

Giancarlo Giannini

The Pope

Eddie Bo Smith Jr.

Theo

Michael Guido

Aaron

Matt Zeigler

Kevin

Colleen Camp

Joan Casey

Marc Grapey

Steve Casey (as Mark Grapey)

Rich Komenich

Ray Persini

Dale Calandra

Leo Persini

Cedric Young

Charlie

Tim Grimm

Bishop Anderson

Jordan Allen

Michael Reed

James Meeks

Muntoe

Bernie Landis

Rabbi Szeneth

John Sierros

Policeman (credit only)

David Pasquesi

Eli Cohen

Tom Brainard

Young Pastor

Tim Decker

Reverend Daily

Linsey Page Morton

Paulina

Beth Lacke

Sally

Tom Roland

Cardinal Riccardo

Coburn Goss

Father Delorenzo (as Coby Goss)

Jim Carrane

Father Tumelo

Ilio Bruno

Cardinal Napoli

Barrie D. Buckner Jr.

Henry (as Barrie D. Buckner)

Jason Borgardt

Randall

Ken Stimson

Reverend Williams

Bob O'Donnell

Bishop Representative

Tai Anderson

Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Brad Avery

Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

David Carr

Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Mark Lee

Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Mac Powell

Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"