Anthony Dexter

Capt. William Kidd

Eva Gabor

Judith Duvall

Alan Hale Jr.

Jay Simpson

James Seay

Bellomont

Richard Karlan

Capt. Avery

Noel Cravat

L'ollinaise

Lyle Talbot

Capt. Pace

Sonia Sorel

Anne Bonney

Michael Ross

Blackbeard

Jack Reitzen

Bartholomew

Robert Long

Calico Jack

William Cottrell

Roberts (as Bill Cottrell)

William Tannen

Steve Castle (as Bill Tannen)

John Crawford

Bonnett

William Schallert

Priest (uncredited)