Jonathan Groff

David

Denis O'Hare

Jon

Corey Stoll

Curly

Dean Stockwell

Hobbs

Dale Dickey

Debbie

Casey Wilson

Martha

Troian Bellisario

Jennifer

Danny Belrose

Tattooed Man

Tommy Hestmark

Fair Man

Tyra Richards

Pregnant Woman

Beth Furumasu

Attendant

Keiko Green

Make Out Woman

Kamyar Jahan

Make Out Man

Zachary Vitale

Military Guy

Marvella McPartland

Old Woman on Bus

Tim Patteron

Bus Driver

Blake Lindsley

David's Mom

Eloy Méndez

Pedro

Cami Storm

Pretty Mexican Girl

Dana Millican

Fair Woman

Louis Hobson

Rob

Vu Pham

Factory Manager

Castillo Morales

Field Worker

Lara Baker

Factory Woman #1

Teresa Wells Jones

Factory Woman #2

Ellen Bloodworth

Curly's Mother

Sean Ghazi

Paul

Brennan Sprecher

Older Son

Alexander Chapin-Plata

Younger Son

Katy Beckemeyer

Blonde Woman

Gloria Alvarez

9:15 Woman

Julie Groff

9:15 Woman's Friend

Jewel Robinson

Tissue Box Woman

Jennifer Oswald

Church Member

Kim Bissett

Church Member (uncredited)

Simos Kalivas

Bar Patron (uncredited)

Karli Klein

Waitress (uncredited)

Katie Klein

Store Patron (uncredited)

Timothy Levine

Church member (uncredited)

Diego Sanchez

Field Worker (uncredited)

Asha Sawyer

Fair Extra (uncredited)

Tyron Strickland

Bus Traveler (uncredited)

Jeremy Evan Taylor

Church Member (uncredited)

Bob Olin

Pastor