Tom Sizemore

Pete Rose

Dash Mihok

Paul Janszen

George DiCenzo

Bartlett Giamatti

Melissa DiMarco

Carol Rose

Sarain Boylan

Katarina Grant

Paulino Nunes

Don Stenger

Paul Fauteux

Tommy Gioiosa

Carlos Diaz

Mike Bertollini

Richard M. Davidson

Alex Karzis

Ron Delaplane

Jayne Eastwood

Marge Schott

Devon Bostick

The Kid

Joe Bostick

Limo Driver

Melanie Marden

Annie #1

Kim Allan

Annie #2

Paul Brogren

Fan

Bruce Tubbe

Tony Perez

Dino Roumel

Baseball Player

Geoffrey Bowes

Tommy Helms

Mike Didier

Buddy Bell

Christopher Lee Clements

Reds Security

Jonathan Whittaker

Doug Duennes

Vincent M. Doria

Waiter

Jeff Christensen

Scott Breedan

Colin Cummins

Dave Parker

Erin Woodward

Annie

Katherine Trowell

Hairdresser

David Macniven

Special Agent Williams

Edie Inksetter

Special Agent Mary ODell

Eric Weinthal

Lie Detector Administrator

Greg Ellwand

Peter Ueberoth

Alan Jordan

Fay Vincent

Ed Durso

Self

Rick Reid

John Dowd

Lawrence Cotton

Bob Pitcairn

Dwayne Hill

Press Conference Reporter

Rory O'Shea

Reporter #1

Kris Ryan

Reporter #2

Robert Williams

Reporter #3

David Farant

Reporter #4

Livingston Beaumont

Reporter #5

Charles Gibson

Self (archive footage)

Kirsten Maryott

Uptown Girl

John Pallotta

Coach

Pete Rose

Self (archive footage)

Michael Sercerchi

Hotel Guest

Ray Donn

Diamond Buyer (uncredited)