David Clayton Rogers

Butch Cassiday

Ryan Browning

The Sundance Kid

Rachelle Lefevre

Etta Place

Michael Biehn

Mike Cassidy

Michelle Harrison

Mary Margaret Place

Blake Gibbons

Durango

Hamish Boyd

Elzy Lay

Jay Brazeau

Railroad Company Executive

Susan Ruttan

Mrs. Place

Mark Consuelos

Sergeant Sanchez

Marty Antonini

Simpkins

Mara Casey

Barmaid

John Escobar

Priest

John Fasano

Blacksmith

Lucia Fasano

Cantina Girl