Amy Adams

Ashley

Embeth Davidtz

Madeleine

Ben McKenzie

Johnny

Alessandro Nivola

George

Celia Weston

Peg

Scott Wilson

Eugene

David Kuhn

Auctioneer

Alicia Van Couvering

Bernadette

Jerry Minor

Scout who stays outside

Matt Besser

Scout who goes in

Will Oldham

Bill Mooney, scout

Frank Hoyt Taylor

David Wark

Bobby Tisdale

Norman at Replacements, Ltd.

Beth Bostic

Lucille, the neighbor

Joanne Pankow

Sissy, David Wark's sister

R. Keith Harris

Bud, young pastor

Kevin Harlow Jasper

Hollerin' Man

Dan McLamb

Hollerin' Man

Jeffrey Dean Foster

Gallery Assistant

Laura Lashley

Gallery Assistant

Chuck Russell

Chuck at Replacements, Ltd.

Tarra Jolly

Tarra at Replacements, Ltd.

Jill Wagner

Millicent, friend at shower

Amy Barefoot

Kitty, friend at shower

Jamie Castlebury

Woman at Shower

Carrie Daniel

Bonnie, friend at shower

John A. Van Couvering

Meerkat Expert

Caitlin Van Hecke

Emily, pastor's wife

Gregory Wagoner

Young Singer at church

John Eddie McGee

Older Singer at church

Teresa Fowler

Nurse #1

Victoria Houston Jackson

Nurse #2

Annette Beatty

Dr. Beatty

Katherine Foster

Pregnant Patient