George Montgomery

Pat Garrett

Neville Brand

Butch Cassidy

Buster Crabbe

Wyatt Earp

Karin Booth

Lorna

Gregory Walcott

Bat Masterson

Malcolm Atterbury

Buffalo Bill Cody

Russell Johnson

Sundance

Richard Devon

Harvey Logan

Morris Ankrum

Mayor Coleman

Dan Riss

Marshal McAfee

Martin Benedict

Young Boy (uncredited)