Dan Blocker

Charley

Nanette Fabray

Sadie

Jim Backus

Staunch

Wally Cox

Mr. Bester

Jack Elam

Kittrick

Henry Jones

Hanson

Mickey Rooney

Indian Tom

Noah Beery Jr.

Eddie

Stubby Kaye

Bartender

Marge Champion

Mrs. Bester

Don 'Red' Barry

Rusty

Hamilton Camp

Mr. Fowler

Tom Basham

Traveler

Iron Eyes Cody

Crazy Foot

James McCallion

Dr. Henry

Byron Foulger

Reverend Marshall

Ray Ballard

Carson

Jack Cassidy

Roger Hand

Susan Saint James

Mrs. Martha Kid (uncredited)

Amzie Strickland

Hotel desk clerk (uncredited)

Charles Cirillo

Townsman (uncredited)

Sig Frohlich

Townsman (uncredited)

Bobby Gilbert

Townsman (uncredited)

Edwin Rochelle

Townsman (uncredited)

Christopher Shea

Boy holding sign (uncredited)

Eric Shea

Boy outside saloon (uncredited)

Olan Soule

Train Conductor (uncredited)